Toronto Life - The Informer

Insider intel on the politics and personalities shaping the city. Sign up for Preview newsletter for weekly updates



Philip Preville: Shark fins, pet store puppies, plastic bags—why Toronto city councillors like to ban things

Philip Preville: Big Ban TheoryRob Ford’s victories rarely last. In fact they only become more stunted as his mayoralty lurches along. For his opening salvo in office he killed Transit City; less than two years later it was reborn. Now his wins can be measured
in minutes.

On June 6, council approved Ford’s proposal to end the five-cent fee on plastic shopping bags. Before he had time to gloat, council members promptly voted to make Toronto the first major Canadian city to prohibit plastic grocery bags altogether. Starting next year, Toronto retailers will provide customers with paper bags.

Ford’s objection to the bag ban is quite simple: he’s a conformist. He wants Toronto to quit messing with the rules all the time and act normal like everyone else. It’s this aspect of his personality that chafes so gratingly against the city he ostensibly rules. Toronto likes to be an early adopter of righteous urbanist innovation, a forward-thinking, environmentally and socially progressive bastion of creative-classist policy-making. Our avant-gardisme has become part of
our identity.

When council voted to ban the bags—which it did rashly, without any research or consultation—its damn-the-torpedoes approach went against Toronto’s penchant for thoughtful deliberation. But the idea of a ban met with broad acceptance anyway because it felt right. It fit the mould. And therein lies the problem. The ban wasn’t about bags at all. It was about identity politics. It was the Exceptional City sticking it to Mayor Hoser. Unfortunately, it’s doomed to fail.

Toronto has been on a vigorous run of progressive policy-making over the last decade. At times, this city has been the first to permit new and worthy things, such as same-sex marriages, for which it issued the first licence in North America on June 10, 2003. On other occasions, Toronto has gone a step further and made worthy new things compulsory, such as green roofs on new buildings over 2,000 square metres (which it did last April, a first in North America) or household waste separation (the green bin program celebrates its 10th anniversary this fall). But mostly, Toronto likes to ban bad things.

Lately, council has been on a badness-banning binge. Last year, it forbade the sale of shark fins and the sale of mill-bred cats and dogs in pet stores. Two years ago, the city restricted the practice of idling a parked vehicle’s engine to 60 seconds, which, compared with the previous three-minute limit, is as close to an outright ban as it can get. In 2008, Toronto banned the sale of bottled water in city facilities. Five years before that, Toronto was among the first Ontario municipalities to ban the use of cosmetic pesticides. The city also has long-standing—and not especially progressive—bans against street hockey and just about any street food other than hot dogs.

Toronto isn’t the only Canadian municipality on the ban-wagon. The plethora of recent embargoes in Mississauga (which included shark fins and mill-bred puppies) earned it the moniker of “Canada’s nanny state” from the pro–nanny state Toronto Star. More broadly, ever since 2001—the year the Supreme Court of Canada ruled that municipalities could ban the use of non-essential pesticides—cities have been pushing the envelope of the forbidden, banning everything from teen tanning to ice cream truck
calliope music.

  • Justin Flontek

    Time to send the blowhards, known as the Fords packing.

  • Chris

    Of course the plastic bag ban was stupid – the 5 cent charge was working just fine (although I admit I always disagreed with the notion that retailers could simply pocket the nickel – the cash should have at least been directed towards something useful) until Ford decided he needed a silly little “victory” and went after somethig he thought would be an easy win and pander to his base. Like everything else he does, it blew it up in his face.

    the irony is that as our City Council is looking to reopen the vote with some hoping we go back to the old days of no plastic bag charge, municipalities all over North America are actually adopting some form of surcharge on plastic bags, or flat-out bans.

    Its amazing to me how we’ve allowed this Council to go from one of the most progressive to one of the most regressive in North America in barely 2 years.

  • Joe M

    Nice cartoon. Did Rob draw that? At least some councilors attempt to do make sort of change for the good in this world.

    These Neo conservative politicians would rather attempt to regress society back to when the citizens had no voice. More money than brains.

  • Kelly

    We elect our councillors to represent the people, not to push their own personal agendas. This ban was obviously done out of spite just to piss off Ford by a bunch of out of touch councillors. I’d like to see they propose how people would bring takeout food home, particularly food from chinatown, without plastic bags. I for one am notoriously cheap; I save every plastic bag I bring into the house and fill it to the brim with garbage prior to disposing of each one (and yes I recycle everything when possible). What’s the difference between using this bag and paying for a box of Glad bags?

  • havingalook2

    Ban this ban that – but there is no one to enforce it. Visit the corner of Richmond and Sherbourne Streets where there happens to be a Tim Horton’s and there are all kinds of idling construction dump trucks, delivery vans, taxies sitting with their engines running. Then there is the Tim Horton’s truck, often idling completely blocking the bike lane – no one enforcing either.

    The worried about bloody plastic bags, and yet no one enforces the by-law about adults riding their bikes on the sidewalk endangering countless pedestrians. So you can motor down a pedestrian and who is going to enforce the $3.75 fine for doing so. What a load of rubbish. You can make all the new laws and bi-laws you fancy – big joke if no one enforces them. A grocery store I went to never started charging for plastic bags – I shopped more there just for the bags. As a dog owner I needed them to pick up after my dog…however others don’t and there is no one enforcing that law either.

    Joke, it is all a big sad joke.

  • marc demers

    too many councillors (twice as many as MP’s and MPP’s) with nothing to do but come up with ways to make themselves look important and intelligent and most importantly – get in the news.
    the rest of Ontario reads and laughs, the rest of Canada reads and ridicule, the rest of the world doesn’t care. And Toronto’s population – we just sit there and cry over their insanity. Yet, incumbants continue to be elected.