Restaurants GuideItalian

Al Fogolàr star star good
star star very good
star star star excellent
star star star star extraordinary
star star star star star perfect

Read a full explanation of our system

Reviewed by Toronto Life
  • 7065 Islington Ave. (at Steeles Ave. W.) View on map »
  • Vaughan
  • 905-851-1166
Editorial Review

Reminiscent of a medieval schnitzel house, the room’s dark wood beams, plaster walls, wrought iron chandeliers and open hearth (or fogolàr) create the feel of a traditional private club—the ideal spot to celebrate a 50th wedding anniversary or have a family supper. Such classic northern Italian fare as grilled polenta, calamari and salt cod are modernized and artfully presented, though unevenly executed. The amazing pappar­delle comes with pieces of succulent roast pheasant and softened cherry tomatoes tossed in a simple rosé sauce that lets the zingy tomato and rosemary flavours shine. Four giant shrimp arrive perfectly butterflied and grilled, but the accompanying veggies (same for all mains) sport a bland parsley pesto that shows the kitchen’s limitations. For dessert, a crispy fried crostoli is devoured alongside a light, boozy tiramisù. A decent wine list and attentive service. Mains $28–$37.

Related Restaurant Reviews

This Italian restaurant captures the essence of Italy in its ...

Lacklustre decor distracts from a menu of smartly executed non-regional ...

This dark, tiny and comfortable room delights with whimsical yet ...

“You haven’t had wedgy fries before?” asks one customer incredulously ...

The brickwork arches, wooden chairs, dusty-pink linens and soft lighting ...

Related Features

Danny Grossman Danny Grossman

How the modern dance guru, whose company performs at Harbourfront this month, would spend a single perfect day. Toronto on ... By Amy Verner

Hog Wild Hog Wild

Sweet, rich and gloriously sinful, Lai Wah Heen’s Wuxi spareribs make a perfect mid-winter meal. So we got chef Ken ...

Under the Influence Under the Influence

Through his short, bright career, Scot Woods has been obsessed with bringing the world’s cuisines to his cooking. Other chefs ... By James Chatto