Restaurants GuideContinental

Blacktree star star good
star star very good
star star star excellent
star star star star extraordinary
star star star star star perfect

Read a full explanation of our system

Reviewed by Toronto Life
  • 3029 New St. (at Guelph Line) View on map »
  • Burlington
  • 905-681-2882
Editorial Review

Hidden at the terminus of a tiny alley in a Burlington shopping plaza, chef-owner Matteo Paonessa’s stylish little jewel-box of a restaurant is ambitious. At its best, the cooking is extraordinary, the flavours more interesting than at many of Blacktree’s big city peers. But Paonessa hobbles the restaurant’s considerable strengths with user-unfriendly flourishes. The chef’s ever-changing à la carte menu is exhibit A, composed of enigmatic names but no descriptions: one evening’s choices include Slambon, Summer Cube, SOS Cucumber Pool and Game, a conceit that necessitates a server’s six-minute recital of what’s actually on offer. When dinner starts arriving, all is almost forgotten. The aforementioned SOS brings scallops, a raw oyster and seared swordfish lolling in a shallow moat of cucumber water and garnished with super-concentrated yellow “chips” made from golden beets. Some of the elements, like the beet chips, are enthralling; others, like the gritty, sand-choked raw oyster, less so. Mains are exceptional: Game, for instance, bringing lightly seared elk that’s nearly as tender as mousse, moist roast quail, intense wine-braised shallots and morels, and a roasted peach. The whole assembly sits atop dark wheat berries and is crowned with a carrot foam. Inventive desserts. Mains $30–$40.

  • Closed Sunday and Monday
Related Restaurant Reviews

The warmly lit dining room overlooks Bay Street, an ideal ...

The ground floor buzzes as friends enjoy a casual night ...

He encapsulated Queen West’s mood as co-creator of Czehoski; now ...

A sleek bar ringed by Bay Street deal makers quaffing ...

Before menus are even presented, the kitchen sends out a ...

Related Features

Danny Grossman Danny Grossman

How the modern dance guru, whose company performs at Harbourfront this month, would spend a single perfect day. Toronto on ... By Amy Verner

Hog Wild Hog Wild

Sweet, rich and gloriously sinful, Lai Wah Heen’s Wuxi spareribs make a perfect mid-winter meal. So we got chef Ken ...

Under the Influence Under the Influence

Through his short, bright career, Scot Woods has been obsessed with bringing the world’s cuisines to his cooking. Other chefs ... By James Chatto