Quest

March 2007

Hot Potatoes

In search of the city's best pierogies By Jenny Koniuk

A peasant staple through much of eastern Europe, pierogies first appeared in Canada on the tables of Ukrainian immigrants settling the prairies in the 1890s. Called “varenyky” or “pyrohy” in Ukrainian, the Polish “pierogi” has long been the name used here. The dumplings are traditionally stuffed with sauerkraut, beef, cabbage or mushrooms (and even sugared cherries), though mashed potatoes and cheese (either cheddar or dry pressed cottage, called farmer’s cheese) have become Canadian favourites. Here are four of the best.

The Place The Package The Presentation The Judgment
Amber European
2372 Bloor St. W.,
416-763-6164, five for $6.50
Beautifully thin, tender dough folded around quality ingredients: earthy potatoes and flavourful farmer's cheese Almost too pretty to eat: flecked with fresh dill, sweet fried onions and bacon bits, and elegantly sided with a wee dollop of sour cream Even prairie-born, pierogi-fed dumpling snobs can't deny it: these are the real deal
Granowska's
175 Roncesvalles Ave.,
416-533-7755, six for $5.25.
Dumplings are wider and thinner than the average, with thickish, tender dough enveloping flavourful potato and cheese Everything does go better with butter. Pierogies are topped with butter-soaked toasted bread crumbs and a smidge of dried parsley and sided with sour cream The most stick-to-your-ribskis of the bunch, though butter-phobes should steer clear
Chopin Restaurant
165 Roncesvalles Ave., 416-536-6228, 10 for $7.95
Ultra-soft, pillowy dumplings, clearly made by hand. Potato and cheddar filling has a satisfying tang Fried onion topping is a little too sparse Cumulus-light, but somehow doughy, as well
European Delight
St. Lawrence Market, lower level
416-365-9010, $4 per dozen
Probably the closest to a homemade dough. Soft, smooth filling with the nip of cheddar Beautifully browned fried onions and a dollop of sour cream Ignore the ugly styrofoam container; pierogies don't get much better than this

More Quest Articles
Gnocked Up
Bone Collector
Humble Pies
Orient Express
Hot Chicks
See all Quest articles »