Toronto Life - The Dish

The latest buzz on restaurants, chefs, bars, food shops and food events. Sign up for the Dish newsletter for weekly updates. Send tips to thedish@torontolife.com

Features

19 Comments

The South Rises: Chris Nuttall-Smith on the best barbecue joints in the GTA

The city’s latest southern-inspired restaurants are serving up smoky, tender, chin-dribbling barbecue. Who cares if it’s not authentic? It’s good

Barque Smokehouse

(Image: Jess Baumung)

After two long and selfless weeks of debilitating meat sweats and overconsumption-related shortness of breath, a host of minor but nonetheless traumatic flossing injuries and at least three grossly inopportune bouts of smoky, tangy, disconcertingly succulent belching, the one thing I know for certain is that the GTA, once lamented for its lack of good southern-style barbecue restaurants, has plenty of excellent choices now.

A wave of new places has upended the city’s long-held notion of barbecue—ribs that came boiled, grilled and slathered in torrents of sticky ketchup-based sauce, to cite just one common example—and replaced it with something that comes much closer to the low-and-slow smoked southern ideal.

THE CRITIC’S TOP FIVE

Number 1

The Stockyards Smokehouse and Larder
699 St. Clair Ave. W., 416-658-9666
Toronto Life review »

Number 2

Barque Smokehouse
299 Roncesvalles Ave., 416-532-7700

Number 3

Big Bone BBQ and Wicked Wings
207 Eagle St., Newmarket, 905-853-9888

Number 4

Paul and Sandy’s Real Barbecue
4925 Dundas St. W., 416-233-7032
Toronto Life review »

Number 5

Buster Rhino’s Southern BBQ
7-2001 Thickson Rd. S., Whitby, 905-436-6986
Toronto Life review »

On the heretofore middling restaurant strip called Roncesvalles, Barque Smokehouse is one of the newest spots. It’s also one of the best. Barque is named for the peppery, wood-smoky, deeply caramelized crust that’s a characteristic of southern barbecue, and the name isn’t an affectation. David Neinstein, Barque’s pit master, makes whole-smoked chickens that are moist and full-flavoured from brining, smoke-stained a deep, telltale pink under their skin (southern barbecue first-timers often mistake the colour for undercooking) and imbued to their cores with the taste of smouldering pecan and apple wood. His brisket, rubbed down with chunky cracked peppercorns, salt and a touch of sugar, is much moister and more charactered than the usual. (I wasn’t surprised to learn that Neinstein reveres the brisket at Schwartz’s deli in Montreal.) His beef ribs are pleasantly creamy and nicely crusted at their edges, while the baby backs are tender but with a little chew left in them, and properly dry, but in a way that sets your mouth to prodigious watering. (An aside for barbecue arch-geeks: he cooks them in a gas-heated, wood-burning Southern Pride smoker, which he had trucked in from Alamo, Tennessee.) At their best, they were punchy and tangy from a black pepper dry rub, but only enough to balance out the meat. This is all the more impressive considering that Neinstein had only two months of experience cooking in restaurants when he opened Barque in April.

Neinstein, who is 32, worked in advertising and did an MBA at the University of Windsor before he committed to opening a restaurant in 2009. Jonathan Persofsky, his 30-year-old business partner, who runs the front of house, was a project manager for a hospital software firm. While this sort of resumé would almost certainly spell sudden, painful death at most other kinds of restaurants, the barbecue business is full of quick studies. With luck, money and (to be sure) a little skill, weekend hobbyists can, and often do, rise to the top of the competitive barbecue circuit in just a couple of seasons.

In the spring of 2010, Neinstein spent eight weeks working at Head Country Barbecue, a respected smokehouse in Ponca City, Oklahoma, where he learned the basics of commercial barbecue and helped cater enormous events for such vital southern U.S. institutions as the National Rifle Association. He also became a certified judge under the Kansas City Barbeque Society (from the judge’s oath: “I accept my duty to be an official KCBS certified judge, so that truth, justice, excellence in barbecue and the American way of life may be strengthened and preserved forever”) and toured some of the South’s standout joints.

How we do it

These restaurants are recommended by our anonymous reviewers. Restaurant bills are paid by Toronto Life; reviews have no connection to advertising. Stars are awarded for food and wine quality, as well as presentation, service, atmosphere, ambition and originality. All of our restaurant reviews can be found at torontolife.com/restaurants/.

What the stars mean

star Good
star Very good
star Excellent
star Extraordinary
star Perfect
  • RAJ

    that’s better.

  • J

    Shame you didn’t include Oakville in your search. Sweet Smoke is outstanding and perhaps more authentic than some of your other pics.

  • Rob

    quite a discussion has ensued on chowhound over Barque

    http://chowhound.chow.com/topics/783927

  • Michael

    I love The Stockyards. It’s affordable ($25-30 for two) and delicious and I love how they serve your meal in a cast iron skillet. With limited seating it is hard to get a seat since it has become so popular. I think I’ve only eaten there 2 of the 5 times I’ve intended to. But on a nice day you can always get take-out and walk over to Wychwood Barns and eat at a picnic table. Try the limeaide.

  • adam

    fuck oakville. this is torontolife.om, not gtalife.com.

  • adam

    ahem. .com.

  • Pete

    Phil’s…end of story

  • Buster Rhino’s

    What was with the backhanded compliment directed at Buster Rhino’s? It’s good, but because it’s in Whitby it sucks? What BS. Buster Rhino beats all of the places you listed including your beloved Stockyards and definitely takes Barque to school.

  • Jean

    Adam,
    grow up and get a life!

  • J

    Whoa there…good food is good food that’s all I’m saying. How different is that than Toronto Life naming Eigensinn Farm one of the top 10 restos in 2009? Just because you can’t access via TTC doesn’t mean it doesn’t count.

  • jaydee

    @ Pete.Phil’s has to be my worst experience with Q. Meat is drier than the bones. Just like Caplanski’s, it lives off TL’s reviews. Doesn’t mean there good…. end of story

  • WalterP

    Picky but in 75 years I can’t recall a stockyard at Wychwood and St. Clair but once I saw the reference to Wychwood Barns it all made sense.

  • tony

    Blue Sage Gourmet Eatery has delicious traditional smoked Southern BBQ and a friendly owner-chef. This GTA restaurant is in Mississauga, south east corner of Eglinton Avenue East and Tomken Road (on the Money Mart and Bell strip)

  • Paul O’Connor

    I agree, Phils was a real disappointment but I have had several dinners at Paul & Sandy’s and the food is excellent and the meat is certainly not dry like I had at Phils. Can’t wait to try both The Stockyards and Barque.

  • didi

    your new food critic sucks!!!!

  • Jason

    Phil’s is the best. nough said

  • need new teeth

    By their own admission of being ‘not purely BBQ’ Barque shouldn’t be on this list.
    Inconsistency apart, even discounting their tough back ribs, the fact that they have a prix-fixe only menu on the weekends is stupifying!

    Until Buster Rhino open shop in T.O. (apparently soon), Stockyards is my one and only stop

  • Jim

    Barque sucks! Their secret ingredient is sodium.

  • Philippe Gaudet

    Just discovered mo.jo Smokehouse in Newmarket. I’ve journeyed to try everyone on the list above and mo.jo needs to be added to the top. #RealDeal.

 

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement